The Washington, D.C. Council's Committee on Human Services advanced B26-0656, an online casinos bill that would regulate sweepstakes casinos under the iGaming framework, by a 3-1 vote on Wednesday.
Much of the discussion covered online casino gaming broadly, but sweeps casinos drew some of the most detailed back-and-forth of the hearing. And, although it’s clear this is a step in a positive direction for the sweeps industry, it isn’t entirely clear what exactly would and wouldn’t be allowed in terms of sweeps gaming.
Here is everything that was said about sweeps during the meeting.
The committee version targets ‘illegal sweepstakes gaming’
Councilmember Matthew Frumin, who chairs the committee, opened by describing the bill as a regulatory measure that brings "an existing active market that operates in an unregulated gray area under strict oversight."
Councilmember Wendell Felder introduced the bill in April. Frumin said the committee’s approved version of the bill built on Felder's version with research on other regulated markets and conversations with responsible gaming organizations and advocates on all sides.
Among the "key enhancements" he listed was a provision aimed squarely at sweeps:
"Regulating Social Plus games under iGaming,” Frumin said, “to ensure there is no backdoor market entrance and to put a stop to illegal sweepstakes gaming in the District."
Impact on free-to-play platforms?
Councilmember Zachary Parker said he generally supports the bill, but sweeps were the first topic he raised. He said he had heard concerns that the bill would treat non-casino-style mobile games, like Candy Crush, the same as iGaming providers:
"One thing that I've heard about the Social Plus gaming or the social games, and I'm thinking of something like Candy Crush, if I'm not mistaken, is that we are now with this bill forcing them to comply with the same regulations as an iGaming provider,” Parker said. “Some of these social gaming platforms are free for users. And there's been some concern that it will cause undue harm to said companies."
Frumin: The dual-currency model ‘won't be allowed’
Frumin singled out the dual-currency model.
"There are categories of games (within Social Plus) … where it's sort of a dual-currency thing where it's free and then you can cash it in and you can buy more of that currency,” he said. “I think those kinds of games are not allowed."
Legislative assistant Emelie Shany confirmed this, and Frumin continued: "So that kind of mode of operation won't be allowed. … And there will be the authority to stop those."
He also said that mode of operation "will need to be regulated," which left it unclear whether the model would be banned or licensed.
Should sweeps pay what Caesars pays?
Parker said he wasn't sure whether games like Candy Crush fall into the category and asked the committee to look at it. He then raised a cost question:
"The question I have is: Should they be paying the same multimillion dollar licensing fees as a Caesars or MGM?” he asked. “And that's a genuine question. I'm not sure what some of these Social Plus gaming's revenue numbers are."
Candy Crush is safe, and sweeps will be regulated like iGaming
Frumin turned the question over to Shany. She drew the line between purely social games and sweepstakes games:
"Games like Candy Crush, which are purely social games, are still allowed in the District,” she said. “We're not taking that away from anyone. What this legislation does is that it regulates iGaming, traditional internet casinos, as well as sweepstakes-based social gaming."
She then described how those games work.
"Those games are, as you described, usually free to play, and there is some sort of buy-in component from players should they choose to do so, and what they get in return for … that purchase is either a Sweeps Coin or a Gold Coin that they can exchange for entries into a sweepstakes that that operator is doing, or potentially cash prizes, depending on the system of that particular game,” Shany said. “Those will be regulated under the same sort of taxation and licensing structure as we have for traditional internet casino games."
Parker restated it in plainer terms: "So grandma's Candy Crush is OK … won't be bothered. But then the sweepstakes games will be held to the same standard as the iGaming regime."
"That is correct," Shany replied.
An industry ‘in the billions’
Parker followed up on revenue, asking whether the committee's research found sweeps gaming companies comparable to a Caesars, "a major behemoth of a company."
"I wouldn't say they're necessarily 1-to-1 comparable with Caesars, as you described,” Shany said. “But the industry is in the billions of dollars."
Frumin added that the committee had engaged with the sweeps industry while drafting the provision: "We've worked with folks in that industry to try to come up with something that works."
Enforcement against the ‘dark market’
Parker then asked how enforcement would work if an operator continues to "operate in the dark market" once the law takes effect, should it pass.
Frumin pointed to the bill's reporting requirements, saying noncompliance "can bring down every form of penalty, including disbarment." For illegal operators, he said, the bill authorizes cease-and-desist orders, an authority he said "doesn't exist now."
Parker said he expected DLCP and the Office of the Attorney General to lead that work, and noted that DLCP "has been reluctant to enforce, even when there are bad actors at play."
What's next?
The bill now heads to the full Council. Frumin told Henderson the committee would work with her on additional consumer protections before first or second reading.
